As 2021 is soon coming to a close, I think there is one
thing we can all agree on… It has been a crazy year, a
crazy controversial year. I think a lot of that controversy
has come from one long lasting debate: Which should be
put first? Personal freedom, or public health?
Well fear no more, I posted a poll to get the
student body’s opinion on this topic and I think I have
found the majority opinion. Covid has agreeably pushed a
lot of people's buttons, but it has also resurfaced a
problem that started long before the 21st century.
The discussion on public health first notably
began in the 1930’s when due to a rapidly growing
automotive industry, lap belts (known today as seat belts)
entered the public's lives. Although seatbelt laws didn’t
become fully implemented until nearly 50 years later,
people still questioned their personal freedom. But that is
just the beginning…
Laws about smoking, driving age requirements,
and other public health concepts have been placed over
the last century. But there is still the argument over
whether the public’s health is worth more than one’s
personal freedom.
Recently, one of the biggest public health
concepts has been Covid requirements. Things like
vaccines, mandates, social distancing, and masks have
been pressured upon the public by the government, peers,
and most of society. But is it right?
Before seeing our own school’s opinion, why don’t
we look at how some experts feel. One expert, Charles
Everett Koop says, “Healthcare is vital to all of us some of
the time, but public health is vital to all of us all of the
time.” Koop was the former United States Surgeon
General from 1982 - 1989 during Ronald Reagan's
presidential term. He was an extremely significant person
in the public health vs. personal freedom debate due to his
role in automotive public health and safety. He was
Surgeon General, the head of public health in the United
States and pressured laws for driving under the influence
and tobacco.
Another expert of public health, David Kessler,
was a pioneer in the controlling of tobacco. He fought to
control the tobacco industry to support the health of the
public. This was yet another revolutionary situation
favoring public health, but let's see what our own student
body thinks about public health.
Firstly, when asked their opinion on masks and a
majority vote said they didn’t really mind them. Students
said that they can be irritable but they appreciate the
feeling of safety that comes with them. Next, when asked
about vaccines, 41% claimed that they liked vaccines and
thought they were useful.
Although many claimed that they liked them, there were
also many comments that were skeptical. Some students
think it would be better if they were tested more and they
knew what exactly it was they were putting in their body,
however there seemed to be an agreement that they can
be useful to prevent disease.
Another question asked was, “How do you feel
about contact tracing?” A very close majority vote ruled
that they didn’t really mind it, with large counts of votes
towards dislike and like coming in close behind. Some
students stated that they wish contact tracing was a little
bit more thought through, but if it keeps people safe it’s the
right thing to do!
Finally, we also asked for an opinion on seat belts.
A wildly controversial topic over the last century. However,
77% voted that they liked them and there were 0 votes
that disliked them. Students said they make them feel
safe and protected!
Overall when asked which they find the most
important, public health or personal freedom, it was a very
mutual opinion. Students thought that public health is
extremely important although personal freedom should
also be taken into mind when enforcing public health
rules. One student said that “if we work together we can
make these requirements no longer feel like rules, just
basic safety!”
In conclusion, there really is no right answer to the
public health, vs. personal freedom debate. We all have
our own opinions and it is important to take that into
account. Public health is very important in order to keep
everyone safe and personal freedom is important to
uphold our democracy and individuality. This applies to
our school as well… We can still have individual rights
and keep everyone safe. We all just need to work
together!
4
5
https://www.newsy.com/stories/the-public-health-vs-personal-freedom-debate-isn-t-new/